Key Takeaways
-
You earn client trust by addressing their skepticism head-on, not avoiding it. Their question, “How do I know you’re not just selling me?” isn’t an objection—it’s an invitation for transparency.
-
Trust isn’t a byproduct of information overload. It’s built when your intentions are clear, your approach is consistent, and your advice remains valuable even if they walk away.
Why That Question Matters More Than You Realize
Every independent insurance agent hears it at some point. Sometimes it’s said out loud. Other times it’s hiding behind a polite nod or a skeptical look. Either way, the client’s concern is the same: “How do I know you’re not just trying to sell me something?”
You’re in a profession where the stakes are high and the public trust is low. That means your response to this silent—or spoken—question can define your career trajectory. If your answer feels defensive, vague, or rehearsed, the opportunity vanishes. But when your response feels honest and grounded, you move from salesperson to trusted professional.
So how do you give an answer that lands? Let’s break that down.
Show, Don’t Just Tell
When clients ask if you’re just selling them, they’re not really asking about the product. They’re asking about your motives.
If you immediately start listing plan benefits, you’re confirming their suspicion. What they need first is evidence of your intentions. And that doesn’t come from your words—it comes from your actions.
-
Lead with questions, not pitches. Ask what matters to them before you explain anything.
-
Pause your recommendations. Let them talk about concerns or hesitations before offering options.
-
Walk through trade-offs openly. No plan is perfect. Show them you’re willing to highlight both pros and cons.
When you do this, your tone shifts from persuasion to partnership. They can sense the difference.
Stop Trying to Overcome—Start Trying to Align
Too many agents treat skepticism like something to overcome. But skepticism isn’t a wall. It’s a signal. It means the client cares. It means they’re paying attention.
Instead of treating their doubt as resistance, try to match it with your own cautious optimism. For example:
-
“That’s a fair question. Honestly, I ask myself the same thing whenever I’m in your shoes.”
-
“I wouldn’t expect you to take my word for it. Let’s take this one step at a time so you can see what I’m seeing.”
When you mirror their mindset, you stop sounding like you’re trying to win. You sound like someone who’s working alongside them.
Make the Risk Real—For You, Not Just Them
Trust grows when the client sees that you also have something to lose. If it’s all upside for you and all risk for them, they’ll stay guarded.
That’s why it helps to talk about:
-
How your reputation depends on long-term relationships.
-
The time you invest in clients who may never say yes.
-
The referrals you earn only when clients feel genuinely taken care of.
You’re not just closing a sale. You’re opening a relationship. When you frame your work in those terms, clients hear something different: commitment.
Use the Power of Silence
It sounds counterintuitive, but one of the best ways to prove you’re not just selling is to stop talking.
If a client voices doubt and you immediately fill the space with stats or reassurances, you may unintentionally come off as pushy.
Instead:
-
Let their comment sit for a moment.
-
Nod or even say, “That’s a good point.”
-
Wait to see if they want to elaborate.
This creates space. In that space, clients often begin to process and express what’s really bothering them. And once it’s out, you can address it directly.
Reframe the Conversation Around Choice, Not Convincing
People fear being sold because they fear losing control. Your job isn’t to convince them that they need you. It’s to help them see their choices clearly.
Here’s how to structure those moments:
-
“Here’s what happens if you go with this option.”
-
“Here’s what happens if you wait six months.”
-
“Here’s what some people choose instead.”
When you speak in terms of possible futures—not desired outcomes—you become their thinking partner, not their persuader. That shift is subtle but powerful.
Drop the Need to Be Right
Sometimes you’ll see a client leaning toward a choice that you know isn’t ideal. Your instinct might be to step in strongly.
Resist that urge.
Trust is built when clients feel safe—even in making mistakes. If they’re wrong, they’ll remember how you treated them more than what you said. If they’re right, your humility will stand out.
Either way, you win by:
-
Offering your perspective without judgment.
-
Leaving room for them to explore and revise their thinking.
-
Letting them know you’ll be there no matter what they choose.
This isn’t about playing it safe. It’s about showing you care more about their autonomy than your accuracy.
Provide Value That Survives the Sale
Ask yourself: If this person never buys anything, will they still feel like our conversation was worth it?
If the answer is no, your approach needs work.
Try this:
-
Share one insight they didn’t know before.
-
Leave them with a clear next step, even if it’s not with you.
-
Send a summary email with pros and cons of the options discussed.
This shows that you’re not just interested in what they can give you. You’re committed to giving something meaningful, regardless of the outcome.
Shift Your Timeline
In 2025, buyers are more informed than ever. Most clients have researched at least 3-5 options before talking to you. They’re not looking for data. They’re looking for a reason to trust someone with that data.
That means your timeline must shift:
-
Short-term persuasion feels intrusive.
-
Long-term clarity feels supportive.
Clients may not decide today. They may not decide this month. But if you treated them with respect and value, they’ll return when the time is right.
In this era, relationships last longer than closing cycles. That’s your competitive edge.
Train Your Gut to Spot Distrust Early
Not all distrust sounds like, “I don’t trust you.”
It might sound like:
-
“Let me think about it.”
-
“Can you send that to me in writing?”
-
“I just need to check with someone first.”
When you hear this, don’t push forward. Pause. Rewind. Ask:
-
“Is there something here that doesn’t quite sit right with you?”
-
“Was there a moment in this conversation that gave you pause?”
Most agents don’t ask. That’s your advantage.
When You Do All This, You Change the Frame
By now, you understand that the question, “How do I know you’re not just selling me?” is less about defense and more about discernment.
The client is already alert. You don’t need to wake them up. You need to meet them where they are: aware, skeptical, and cautiously hopeful.
When your answers are steady, respectful, and centered on their agency, you don’t need to sell. You just need to serve.
That’s the work. That’s the win.
Build Stronger Conversations With Bedrock Support
When you respond to skepticism the right way, you don’t just keep the conversation alive—you elevate it.
At Bedrock Financial Services, we help independent professionals like you refine your messaging, automate your workflows, and attract clients who stay longer and refer more.
Our tools and training give you more than scripts. We help you build skillsets that turn hesitation into trust and conversations into lifelong relationships.
If you’re ready to upgrade how you handle your next client doubt, sign up with us today.
